HISTORY
GRADE 12
PAPER 2
NSC PAST PAPERS AND MEMOS
SEPTEMBER 2017
SECTION A: SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS
QUESTION 1: WHAT CONTRIBUTION DID STEPHEN BANTU BIKO MAKE TO THE FREEDOM STRUGGLE IN SOUTH AFRICA IN THE 1970s?
SOURCE 1A
The following extract focuses on the philosophy of Black Consciousness. It was written by G. Bizos.
The Black Consciousness Movement (BCM) was engaged in welfare, medical and self-help programmes. Steve Biko, as one of the founders of the BCM, was heavily involved in the running of Black Community Programmes (BCP), which he joined in August 1972 after quitting his medical studies at the University of Natal. He described the rationale (purpose) behind the organisation as: [From: Steve Biko In No One To Blame? In Pursuit Of Justice In South Africa by G. Bizos] |
SOURCE 1B
The following source outlines the interaction between Donald Woods and the Minister of Justice, J.T. Kruger, on the death of Steve Biko.
I once went to Mr. J.T. Kruger and begged him to lift the restrictions on Steve and to speak to him. The result of that visit was an increase in Steve’s restrictions and a state prosecution against me. No assault – no cover-up — Kruger [From: No.46: Steve Biko by H. Bernstein] |
SOURCE 1C
This extract by Nadine Gordimer, an ANC member, pays tribute to Steve Biko.
Somewhere in one of my novels written during the worst years of the apartheid regime, a character says: ‘In a world of so much evil and so much compromise with evil, it means something special to be living in a country where there are still heroes.’ [From: A Resource To Inform Us Our Present and Future by Nadine Gordimer] |
SOURCE 1D
This cartoon by Zapiro commemorates the legacy of Black Consciousness leader, Stephen Bantu Biko.
[From: The Sowetan, 12 September 1997]
QUESTION 2: DID THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION (TRC) BRING ABOUT PEACE AND RECONCILATION IN SOUTH AFRICA?
SOURCE 2A
The following extract describes the composition and work of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC).
The TRC came into being early in 1996, under the joint leadership of Archbishop Desmond Tutu and former cleric and liberal politician, Alex Boraine. Other commissioners spanned the racial and political spectrum. Its tasks were to examine human rights abuses on all sides between 1960 and 1994, hear testimony from victims and perpetrators and, where there was full disclosure and political motivation was clearly present, grant perpetrators amnesty from civil prosecution or civil action. The objective was to encourage truth-telling. Separate amnesty hearings were held for this purpose. If perpetrators did not make use of this opportunity, it was made clear; they would be liable for prosecution. The TRC was also asked to suggest how victims could be compensated through reparations.
[From: Every Step Of The Way by the Department of Education] |
SOURCE 2B
This source is an extract of Lerato Mbele’s interview that she conducted with F.W. De Klerk and Cyril Ramaphosa on SABC 3 on 30 April 2006.
F.W. DE KLERK: The TRC process was flawed in many respects: numerous atrocities (killings) of the past have not been properly investigated; there was an over-emphasis on the role of the former security forces; the assassination of about 400 top IFP leaders has not been thoroughly probed; there has not been an in-depth analysis of what many would call ‘black-on-black’ violence. These flaws create an imbalance which tarnishes the credibility of the TRC. Furthermore I think the TRC failed to get to the core of understanding the past, or building understanding thereof. There is unfinished business, but we must now live the spirit of the Constitution. We must have Ubuntu ... instead of seeking vengeance. We should have reparation, instead of retaliation. If prosecutions go ahead, they must be even-handed: there must be prosecution of undisclosed crimes from all sides, not just from one side. I’ve never been in favour of blanket amnesty, but it will have a tremendous negative effect if we now get a situation that can be interpreted as a witch hunt. We must strike a balance. Prosecution in exceptional cases can be justified, if it is clear that people have hidden the truth of serious crimes for which they should have applied for amnesty. CYRIL RAMAPHOSA: F.W. De Klerk uses emotive (sensitive) words when he says ‘witch hunt’. The term ‘witch hunt’ has never been part of the lexicon (dictionary) of the new South Africa. Nelson Mandela in leading this country to unity and reconciliation made sure that there would not be any blanket ‘witch hunt’ type of process. We are not accustomed to witch hunts; we are, however, as an emerging democracy, accustomed to justice. If crimes were committed in the past, by whomever, and no application for amnesty was made when the opportunity was there, justice must prevail. [From: Truth and Reconciliation in South Africa 10 years on by C. Villa-Vicencio & F. du Toit] |
SOURCE 2C
The following is part of a testimony that Mamanki Sepei (mother of Stompie Sepei) gave at the TRC hearings.
On the 13th of February 1989, they took my son and we went to Brixton. We went to Diepkloof Mortuary. That’s where I identified Stompie. His body was decomposed, but your son is your son. I was fighting for my rights. There were signs that really indicated to me that it was Stompie. After having been killed he was thrown into the river between new Canada and Soweto. You couldn’t even identify him. [From: http://www.justice.gov.za/trc/media 5C1996 5C9605/s960508d.htm. Accessed on 23 November 2016.] |
SOURCE 2D
The photograph below shows members of the ANC Women’s League carrying posters supporting Winnie Mandela during the TRC hearing.
[From: http://www.gettyimages.com/detail/news-photo/may-2004-women-show-their-support-for winnie-madikizela-news-photo/107145359#may-2004-women-show-their-support-for-winnie madikizelamandela-a-picture-id107145359. Accessed on 23 March 2017]
QUESTION 3: WHAT WAS THE IMPACT OF GLOBALISATION ON THE ECONOMIES OF DEVELOPING COUNTRIES AFTER 1989?
SOURCE 3A
This source deals with the impact that global change had on agriculture and how it affected the international economy.
Research on the agricultural impacts of global change frequently emphasises the physical and socio-economic impacts of climate change, yet global changes associated with the internationalisation of economic activity may also have significant impacts on food systems. Together, climate change and globalisation are exposing farmers to new and unfamiliar conditions. Although some farmers may be in a position to take advantage of these changes, many more are facing increased vulnerability, particularly in the developing world. This paper considers the dynamics of agricultural vulnerability to global change through the example of southern Africa. We demonstrate that the combination of global and national economic changes is altering the context under which southern African farmers cope with climate variability and adapt to long-term change. We find that farmers who formerly had difficulty adapting to climatic variability may become less vulnerable to drought-related food shortages as the result of trade liberalisation. At the same time, however, removal of national credit and subsidies may constrain or limit adaptation strategies of other farmers, leaving them more vulnerable to climate variability and change. [From: Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change by Leichenko and O’Brien] |
SOURCE 3B
This poster by the South African Social Protection Experts Network (SASPEN) outlines how poor communities in Southern African countries can improve their living conditions.
[From: http://www.fao.org/3/a-c0012e.pdf. Accessed on 15 November 2016]
SOURCE 3C
This source outlines the viewpoints of two students on the effects of globalisation.
View by Domschu: Moreover, the number of people worldwide who live in abject poverty is deeply troubling. It would be wrong to conclude that globalisation has caused this divergence, or that nothing can be done to improve the situation. Far from it: the low-income countries could not easily integrate into the global economy as others, partly because of their chosen policies and partly because of factors beyond their control. No country, least of all the poorest, can afford to remain isolated from the world economy. Each country should try and reduce poverty. The international community should endeavour to provide the poorest countries – by strengthening the international financial system, through trade and aid – to integrate into the global economy to grow faster and reduce poverty. This is the way to take care that all people in all countries have access to the benefits of globalisation. View by Christian Kalytta: In my opinion the globalisation has, a lot of positive effects. For example there is a global market for companies to trade their products and a wider range of options for people, to choose from among the products of different nations. Furthermore, communication among the countries is on the rise, which allows for better understanding and broader vision. When communication increases amongst two countries, there is interchange of cultures as well. We get to know more about the other’s cultural preferences and probably learn from the economy of other nations. There are also disadvantages, when one mentions globalisation. In my opinion, globalisation is causing a movement of jobs from European to Asian countries. This is the result of lower costs of labour in the Asian countries compared to other countries. The high rate of profit for the companies, in Asia, has resulted in a pressure on the employed Europeans, who are always under the threat of the business being outsourced. [From: https://laboureconomics.wordpress.com/2012/05/14/causes-and-effects-of-globalization-6/. Accessed on 15 November 2016] |
SOURCE 3D
This source explains the negative effects that globalisation had on developing countries.
It is not only the developed nations that are complaining about the negative effects, people in developing nations – where most of the industries have been set up, have their own set of reasons against globalisation. They often complain that their cities have been reduced to garbage-dumps where all industrial waste is accumulated and pollution levels are sky-high. [From: http:/www.buzzle.com/articles/negative effects of globalisation.html. Accessed on 23 November 2016] |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Visual sources and other historical evidence were taken from the following: