QUESTION 4 4.1 4.1.1 C ✓ Solvency 4.1.2 D ✓ Liquidity 4.1.3 B ✓ Return on equity 4.1.4 A ✓ Gearing (4) 4.2.1 ORDINARY SHARE CAPITAL: AUTHORISED SHARE CAPITAL 1 500 000 ordinary shares ISSUED SHARE CAPITAL Presentation, incorrect or no details -1 (max -1) 900 000 | Ordinary shares on 1 July 2015 | 9 180 000 | ✓(75 000) | Shares re-purchased (Average: R10,20) | ✓✓ (765 000) | ✓125 000 | Shares issued (R10,80 per share) | ✓1 350 000 | ✓950 000 | Ordinary shares on 30 June 2016 Operation one part correct; Repurchase deducted & Issued added | 9 765 000 (7) | RETAINED INCOME: Presentation, incorrect or no details -1 (max -2) Balance on 1 July 2015 | 360 000 | Net profit after tax | 444 500 | Funds used for repurchase of shares 75 000 ✓ x 0,50 ✓ (10,70–ASP used) OR (802 500–figure from OSC) One part correct | (37 500) ✓ Do not accept 0 | Ordinary share dividends Must be in brackets or subtracted One part correct | (481 250) ✓ | Interim (434 250✓ – 162 000✓) One part correct OR 481 250 one mark – 209 000 one mark | 272 250✓ Do not accept 162 000 | Final | 209 000 ✓ | Balance on 30 June 2016 Operation, one part correct Must subtract repurchased shares and OSD | 285 750✓ | (9) 4.2.2 Calculate the change in loan for the Cash Flow Statement. 8 000 000 – 4 500 000 = 3 500 000 ✓✓ No part marks (2) Calculate the income tax paid for the Cash Flow Statement. 23 400 ✓ + 190 500 ✓ – 6 200 ✓ = 207 700 ✓ One part correct OR – 23 400 – 190 500 + 6 200 = –207 700 OR T-account with figures on correct sides Debit | Credit | 207 700 | 23 400 | 6 200 | 190 500 | (4) 4.2.3 Net change in cash and cash equivalents | ✓ 808 000 | Cash and cash equivalents (beginning of year) –610 500 one mark +7 500 one mark | ✓✓ (603 000) | Cash and cash equivalents (end of year) | ✓ 205 000 | (4) 4.2.4 Calculate the acid-test ratio on 30 June 2016. 1 015 000 one mark – 564 000 one mark 451 000 two marks (246 000 ✓ + 205 000 ✓) : 635 200 ✓ = 0,7 : 1 ✓One part correct; must be y:1 (4) Calculate the debt-equity ratio on 30 June 2016. 8 000 000 ✓ : 10 050 750 ✓ = 0,8 : 1 ✓One part correct; must be y:1 Accept 0,79 : 1 (3) Calculate the % return on average shareholders' equity (ROSHE) for the year ended 30 June 2016. 4 44 500 ✓ x 100 ½ ✓ (10 050 750✓ + 9 540 000✓) 1 9 795 375 (3 marks) = 4,5% ✓One part correct; cannot be Rands, cents, units etc (5) Calculate the net asset value per share (NAV) on 30 June 2016. 10 050 750 ✓ x 100 = 1 058 cents ✓One part correct OR R10,58 OR 1057,9 cents 950 000 ✓ See 4.2.1 Must be Rands or cents (3) 4.2.5 The liquidity of the company has improved. Quote THREE financial indicators to support this statement. Provide figures and trends. THREE valid indicators ✓✓✓ Figures and trends ✓✓✓ Current ratio – 0,3 : 1 to 1,6 : 1 Acid-test ratio – 0,1 : 1 to 0,7 : 1 see 4.2.4 Debtors' collection period – 43 days to 36 days Do not accept creditors' payment period and stock turnover rate If more than three indicators shown, -1 for superfluous / foreign indicator; max -2(6) 4.2.6 Provide calculations to show the change in the dividend pay-out policy. Comparison of DPS to EPS for 2015 ✓ Calculation / implied calculation ✓ Comparison of DPS to EPS for 2016 ✓ Calculation / implied calculation ✓ Possible calculations for two marks each: - 2015: 35/58 = 60,3% OR 0,6:1 OR Paid out most of earnings/more than 50%
- 2016: 55/51 = 107,8% OR 1,1:1 OR Paid out more than earnings
Possible responses for one mark each: - 2015: Paid out 35c of 58c earnings / retained 23c of 58c earnings
- 2016: Paid out 55c of 51c earnings / paid out 4c from previous earnings (4)
Explain why the directors decided to change the policy. State ONE point with figures. Any ONE valid explanation ✓ Relevant figures ✓ Responses for two marks: To satisfy shareholders for: - ROSHE decreased (from 6,2%) to 4,5%. see 4.2.4
- Market price decreased (from 1 030 cents) to 1 000 cents.
- EPS decreased (from 58 cents) to 51 cents.
Do not accept NAV going down; this is a result of the decision. Responses for one mark: - Satisfy shareholders / Encourage new shareholders
- To get directors re-elected at AGM (2)
4.2.7 - Calculate Mary's % shareholding on 1 October 2015 after repurchase of shares.
Do not award this mark if another figure added 420 000✓ x 100 = 50,9% ✓One part correct Accept 51% (900 000✓ – 75 000✓) Must be below 100%; % sign not essential 825 000 two marks (4) - Explain how Mary has benefitted from the decision to repurchase the shares.
Explanation ✓✓ Part-mark for unclear / incomplete answer Mary became the majority shareholder (2) - The independent auditor discovered that Mary had made the decision to repurchase the shares without informing the board of directors. Why should the independent auditor be concerned about this?
Responses for two marks: ✓✓ Part-mark for unclear / incomplete answer
- Not good corporate governance / Not in accordance with King Code
- CEO cannot make these decisions without getting board approval
- Considered to be insider trading / Abuse of position for personal benefit
- Unethical / Not transparent
Responses for one mark: Not good / not right / King Code / Corporate governance / Could have outvoted other shareholders or directors(2) 4.2.8 The Cash Flow Statement reflected fixed assets purchased to the amount of R4,5 million. Mark source first. If this correct, decision must match source. Explanation must be relevant to the source. Major sources of funding with figures (over R1 000 000 each) | Good/Bad decision | Explanation with financial indicators/figure Explanation ✓✓ Figures ✓✓ | Source 1: Increase in loan - R3 500 000 Source ✓ Figures ✓ Reference can be made to 2015 indicators. | Bad ✓ | The company is negatively geared. ROTCE (8,2%) is lower than the interest rate on loans (12%). Must compare interest rate to ROTCE. OR Financial risk increased. The debt-equity ratio increased from 0,5 : 1 to 0,8 : 1 (See 4.2.4). Must be regarded as bad as there is negative gearing. | Source 2: Issue of shares - R1 350 000 Source ✓ Figures ✓ | Good ✓✓ | Shares were sold for R10,80 per share which is greater than the market price of R10,30 (2015) or R10,00 (2016) or NAV of R10,60. OR If this amount was borrowed, interest of 12% will be payable / Has reduced the risk as D/E ratio would have been higher than 0,8:1. OR Mary is no longer the majority shareholder; owns 44% of the shares. | | OR Bad | ROSHE decreased from 6,2% to 4,5% See 4.2.4 EPS decreased from 58c to 51c NAV could have been higher than 1058c | (10) TOTAL MARKS : 75 |